Simply White vs Chantilly Lace Benjamin Moore Paint Color Review

Simply White vs Chantilly Lace Benjamin Moore Paint Color Review // www.TantrumsandTools.com

How Does Benjamin Moore Paint Color Chantilly Lace Compare to Simply White?

If you’ve gotten to the point where you’re asking about Simply White vs Chantilly Lace Benjamin Moore paint, you already know two necessary things.

First, not all white paint isn’t 100% pure white. Second, not all paint brands are created equal.

Oh, and deciding on a white paint color is not as easy as it seems.

What makes the slight difference?

If you answered undertones, you’re correct! These tricky little things make all the difference between the best white paint colors. 

The perfect white is a matter of personal preference. And a little understanding of how to pick the perfect white.

Let’s get to talking about these popular white paint colors; Benjamin Moore Simply White and Chantilly Lace.


Just a friendly reminder: This tutorial and any opinions or recommendations are genuinely mine, but this is not a substitute for consulting a professional. I also use affiliate links to earn a commission.


What is the Difference Between Simply White and Chantilly Lace?

There are a handful of the most popular white paint colors floating around. Two of which are Benjamin Moore paint colors Simply White and Chantilly Lace. And you may be wondering what the biggest difference between these two.

It comes down to the warm undertones of Simply White. Simply White is warmer than Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace. There is more to their differences than this, so keep reading to find out!

Benjamin Moore Simply White Paint Color Review

Benjamin Moore Simply White Paint Color Sample // Simply White vs. Chantilly Lace Benjamin Moore Paint  Review // www.TantrumsandTools.com

Benjamin Moore Simply White reportedly has yellow undertones, which makes it a warm white. But it’s not creamy white. And not to confuse you, but it also looks cool when paired with cool tones. Personally, I think it’s almost stark white. But not in an institutional type of way. If you know what I mean.

I’ve used Simply White in two very different places. The first was in my glamper (glamorous camper), and I painted just about everything in Simply White, every wall, trim, table base, and kitchen cabinets! The second was in my most recent project, my mudroom/laundry room combo. Both are smaller spaces with low to medium amount of natural light.

After both projects, I can say that this is a bright white. But when paired with the right lighting, this has a modern, fresh, and clean feel. I mean, who doesn’t want these things?

But I’ll be honest: I opted not to paint the rest of my house this color. Not because it’s not a great color. But because it was a tad too cool.

Does Benjamin Moore Simply White Look Yellow?

No, not even close. There is nothing about Simply White that says yellow. I’ve read endless insights on paint colors and have used this color for myself and have never considered this to look yellow.

Let me share if you’re worried about white paint pulling yellow. The white paint color that pulls yellow is Alabaster. People will try to convince you otherwise, but after using this throughout my entire home, I can tell you that if I had to say there was one obvious undertone, it was yellow.

Benjamin Moore’s Chantilly Lace Paint Color Review

Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace Paint Color Sample // BM Simply White vs Chantilly Lace // www.TantrumsandTools.com

Chantilly Lace OC-65 is one of Benjamin Moore’s whitest white paint colors. It’s part of their off-white color collections and has very little undertones. Once on the wall, it looks like fresh cotton and pure silk.

This color pairs beautifully with finishes and decor with a slight grey or blue hue. Carrara marble is a perfect complement to Chantilly lace because of this paint color’s subtle undertones of blue. 

These undertones are what make Chantilly Lace a cool-toned color. I’d say not too cool where you actually feel cold in your space (yes, this is a real thing!). It’s the perfect contemporary, crisp white.

Consider Sherwin Williams High Reflective White if you’re a diehard Sherwin Williams paint fanatic. This color is the most comparable to Benjamin Moore’s Chantilly Lace.

Why is Chantilly Lace Paint Color So Popular?

Chantilly Lace is so popular because it’s so adaptable. It’s sharp and clean and suits a wide variety of decorating styles.

This color is often used on trim, walls, cabinets, and exteriors. Contemporary, farmhouse, traditional, and so on use this color in their designs. See the versatility?

Is Chantilly White Too White?

Too white is a personal preference dependent on many factors, which I’ll get into if you keep reading! Yes, Chantilly lace is super white. But is it too white?

There are a few situations that I can think of where this white is going to be too white and not right for you. 

  • Minimal sunlight: On a gloomy day, you’ll have a not-so-cozy feeling space because of the blue undertones. This may not be the perfect white for you if you live where the sun is hard to come by. 
  • North-facing rooms: This direction pulls the blue out of the paint, making it feel even cooler.
  • Ambient lighting: Chantilly Lace will be way too white with artificial light that uses bright white or daylight bulbs. 
YouTube video
Tiffany Leigh Design // Top 5 White Paints

Benjamin Moore Paint Quality

Yes, Benjamin Moore paint brand is one of the top paint brands available. It’s easy to use, stain resistant and has excellent coverage.

Benjamin Moore paint brand produces vibrant, rich colors that will last for years without fading. Sherwin Williams (on the pricier end) and Behr (on the more affordable end) are leading competitors of Benjamin Moore.

Easiest Way to Sample Paint Colors on the Wall

Is there anything more frustrating than narrowing down the perfect white paint color options? Yes, there sure is, and it’s having to try all the different colors in real life on the wall! 

Doesn’t seem so bad? Think again! Each sample requires at least two coats. Each white looks different throughout a single room, so you’ll also need to test your colors in multiple room locations. 

Oh, and between each color, you either need a brush for each sample or wash the brush between each color. Trust me, this gets old real quick!

The solution? Skip the paint store, at least for now, because the easiest and most accurate way to trial paint is Samplize. They have the most genius product that helps you choose the right color without all the fuss.

Samplize Peel and Stick Paint Samples

With Samplize, there is less waste with no jars of leftover paint. There are fewer trips to the sink to wash out my brush. And I get the most accurate idea of the paint color in the room because the sample squares are so easy to move around. 

I’ve used Samplize in my own home for more projects than I can recall. There is something very satisfying about slapping peel and stick paint samples on the wall and instantly seeing what the paint will look like. 

How to Choose the Right White Paint Color for Walls

Still can’t decide on which white paint color is best for you? Is your head spilling talking about popular whites, cooler white, warm whites, neutral whites… ahhh!!

My advice is to stop reading and start sampling! I’m the queen of overthinking, so I get it. But sometimes, you need to stop researching and just go for it. 

These color packs make it easy to choose the right white. Grab your samples here:

How to Choose Paint Colors for Your Home Interior

Searching the internet and Pinterest are great places to start in the paint selection process. But after a while, your head will begin to spin.

I found these sources helpful in coming up with a handful of paint color choices, but the wheels fell off when I started a deep dive into each. There were many interpretations of each color, often contradicting each other.

Don’t get me wrong. Although online searching can make you question everything you know about color, they are helpful. You just need to know what to look for! Below are the things I considered when choosing a paint color.

Here are 6 tips to help your paint selection process not seem so hard: 

  • Undertones: subtle or not, the undertones matter tremendously. This info is readily available online and necessary for whether a paint color will work for you.
  • Tone: each color will tend towards either cool or warm tones. Knowing which you prefer helps you to keep or discard an option.
  • Natural light and room direction: more on this below, so keep reading!
  • Decor and other finishes contribute to pulling undertones out of a color, and both must coordinate to achieve good design.
  • In Room Trail: don’t assume that just because a color worked in one room, it will also work in another. Trialing each color in every space is a must (and that is why peel-and-stick paint samples are so amazing).
  • Paint Quality: higher quality paint is worth it. You don’t necessarily need the highest quality, but you don’t want to go too cheap because it does affect your color. 

Room Direction

When I started learning about paint colors, I paid little attention to what I read about room direction. But, after painting my north-facing room in a paint color with purple undertones, I realized I should have cared more about this. 

Why? Because had I listened, I would have known that north-facing rooms pull blueish tones, which would magnify the intensity of the purple in my paint color. I could have saved myself a weekend of work and $100 worth of paint.

Here is what you need to know about room direction and paint colors:

  • North-facing: these rooms have less natural light, which magnifies cooler and blueish tones
  • South-facing: there is a consistent amount of bright light in these rooms, which intensifies the paint color
  • East-facing: the mornings are brightest in an east-facing room, and the light has a yellow-orange tone which will exaggerate a paint color that has any of these colors as undertones
  • West-facing: these rooms have warm evening light, which will intensify any red-orange tones

When comparing Simply White vs Chantilly Lace Benjamin Moore paint, you may wonder which is best for you. Hopefully, knowing Simply White is warmer because of slight yellow tones, and Chantilly Lace is cooler because of the subtle blue undertones makes your decision easier.

Even knowing this, if you like both colors, I suggest using more than just the opinions of online reviews. Get yourself some samples and see for yourself. Once you pick a color, I would love you to share what you decided to use with me in the comments!

Hey Friend!

project planner pack

Every successful DIY project starts with a plan. That’s why I created the Project Planner Pack.

It’s everything you need to complete your project on time and on budget.

Unleash your creativity with a click, download your Planner Pack and start your DIY journey today!


furniture flipping // diy projects // home renovations // modern farmhouse decorating ideas